Sometimes the best creative work comes from having to work within restrictions imposed from outside. The Mind Robber is a perfect example of this. The story before, The Dominators, was originally meant to be a six-parter, but had to be cut down to five (thankfully, as it’s the most awful mess imaginable from every possible standpoint).


So OK, you’ve got to do an extra episode for the next story. Luckily, the next story is set in an alternate dimension, so you can do an episode about getting into that dimension. Stretch out the cliffhangers a bit and suddenly your four-part story becomes a five-parter.

But you’ve got no budget for costumes, or sets, or extra speaking parts for this first episode, because you used all the budget for six episodes on The Dominators. Fine. Borrow two robot costumes from an old Out Of The Unknown episode, and the first episode is set in a mysterious void that happens to look exactly like a plain white room with no distinguishing features whatsoever.

The juvenile lead goes down with chickenpox? OK. Have him lose his face, and the Doctor has to put it back together, and he does it wrong. Recast for a couple of episodes and keep going.

When The Mind Robber was made, TV was still from a primarily theatrical tradition, and the show had to go on. Problems which would cause cancellations of the entire series these days (or which could be ignored because of the much lazier schedules used by modern productions) just had to be worked round. It was only a few years since the only TV was live. Doctor Who’s first producer, Verity Lambert, had, remember, made her name by managing to keep a live drama going even though the lead actor died half-way through. A spot of chicken-pox was nothing in comparison.

What is astounding is how well the result holds up, even to modern eyes. A lot of this is because this is the first story directed by David Maloney, one of three candidates for best director the show ever had (the other two being Douglas Camfield and Graeme Harper). But it’s also down to the story. I have a friend with a seven-year-old daughter, and the daughter adores The Mind Robber – it’s her single favourite Doctor Who story. And for good reason.

We talk a lot on Mindless Ones about metafiction, and this is the single most metafictional Doctor Who story ever. It’s no coincidence that in League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen: Century 1969 it’s Pat Troughton’s Doctor who gets a cameo, and the Karkus, the in-story fictional superhero seen in The Mind Robber also appears.


Because this is a story in which the Doctor, Jamie and Zoe (who, incidentally, is by far the best companion ever in the TV series, being one of the few to actually be the Doctor’s intellectual equal and to regularly be treated as such in the stories – ignore all that nonsense about Russel Davies being the first writer to have a companion who isn’t just a screamer) get trapped in the Land Of Fiction, a world in which distinctions between the real and the imaginary have no meaning.

Here, things stop existing if you know they’re fictional, but fictions can hurt you if you don’t know for sure they’re not real (so Zoe can defeat the Batman parody The Karkus because she’s read his comic-strip adventures, but the Doctor can’t because he hasn’t. See? Reading comics could one day save your life).

The landscape is literally made of words (sorry…) and populated by characters from fiction, either thinly-veiled (the children who appear are from E. Nesbit’s The Railway Children but never named as such for copyright reasons) or public domain (Lemuel Gulliver, who starts out only being able to speak lines from Gulliver’s Travels but gains more agency as the story progresses).

And in control of this landscape is The Master (of the Land Of Fiction), one of several dry runs over the next year or two for the more famous character of a similar name. This one has the appearance right – black gloves, pointy black beard – but is not so evil, being instead a writer of pulp fiction who has been transported to this other dimension to give it life.

This Master is, roughly, meant to be Frank Richards, the writer of the Greyfriars stories among many others (and the principal subject of Orwell’s great essay Boys’ Weeklies), but is a much less impressive figure – whereas Richards published around 75,000,000 words of fiction in his lifetime, The Master wrote a piffling half a million. (For comparison, I published a quarter of a million words, give or take, in 2011).

But all this, of course, is pointing the way to the pop-Platonism that runs as an undercurrent through much of Doctor Who, and which we’ll be dealing with more and more as this series progresses. The Karkus exists to the extent that someone believes in him, and only exists in this reality at all because Zoe has read his adventures. These are, in a very real sense (sorry), the Platonic Forms of the characters – this is an adventure in Platonia.

One can easily draw a line here between this story and the Doctor’s statement decades later that all stories are true (from which we get Teatime Brutality’s wonderful graphic on ‘canon’ above, taken from this post, which should be the last word on any discussion of the subject), but the idea is not quite yet fully formed, because there’s a crucial difference between our heroes and the fictional characters.

We notice this when the Doctor copes, perfectly unfazed, with Jamie’s new appearance – Jamie’s still Jamie, even if he looks like Hamish Wilson rather than Frazer Hines for a little while. But when Jamie and Zoe are made into fictional characters, he’s horrified. Because fictional characters have no agency. They’re the work of an author, and have no free will themselves. They’re controlled entirely by someone else. And this is, of course, the ultimate horror in Doctor Who – the loss of individuality, of agency, and its replacement with control by others.

Later Doctor Who stories, especially those by Paul Magrs, will have a more nuanced view of this. Because of course Doctor Who itself has no single author – and is, indeed, not a single story. I’m constructing one narrative of Doctor Who by my choice of which stories to pay attention to, and every viewer will do something different. And the character of the Doctor lives in those very different narratives, and to the extent one accepts this Platonic worldview at all (I don’t, but my favoured interpretation of the series does) has rather more agency than those characters who have a ‘canon’, an accepted set of stories that do and do not count. Gulliver can only speak in lines from Gulliver’s Travels until the Doctor gives him a little more freedom, but the Doctor can do and say what he likes.

Which is just as it should be.

95 Responses to “Doctor Who: Fifty Stories For Fifty Years: The Mind Robber”

  1. New Doctor Who Post on The Mindless Ones « Sci-Ence! Justice Leak! Says:

    [...] In which I look at The Mind Robber. Share this:PrintEmail Tagged with: Doctor Who, links, me elsewhere [...]

  2. Zom Says:

    That’s a lovely little post. Really enjoyed the mini-anno too.

  3. Illogical Volume Says:

    Yeah, top stuff Andrew, very concise, and exciting even to a Doctor Who novice like me!

  4. Andrew Hickey Says:

    Thanks. I know it’s a short one, but I thought it’d been too long anyway since the last one and I’d just bang out something that hit the main points. A lot of this will be expanded on in the next forty-four of these…

  5. Rachel Kate Says:

    Ooh, so glad you did this one! One of my favorites. And I definitely agree with you about Zoe — brilliant, adventurous, a librarian AND she gets to wear an outfit that makes her look like Emma Peel reimagined by Liberace? That’s pretty much everything I aspire to in life right there. :)

  6. Thrills Says:

    I second that this is dead good stuff, even to someone who isn’t super-hip to old Dr Who (my era’s Sylvester McCoy/huge gap/Eccleston).

    “brilliant, adventurous, a librarian AND she gets to wear an outfit that makes her look like Emma Peel reimagined by Liberace? That’s pretty much everything I aspire to in life right there. :)”

    I also second that. If only a library would give me a job! The library world is hard to get into, just like a spangly catsuit.

    Cheers for the link to the Orwell “Boys’ weeklies” thing, too. Never seen that before! I am going to print it out and read it on the bus, like the modern man I am.

  7. Andrew Hickey Says:

    Ha – Rachel, I can just imagine you dressed like Zoe, actually.

    Thrills, if you haven’t read Orwell’s essays, you really, *really* should – he’s the single best thinker about the intersections between culture and politics I’ve ever come across, and a huge inspiration for me. His non-fiction is much, much better than even his most famous fiction.

  8. 7 things I learned this week: | Inflatable Ink Says:

    [...] in the golden days of Doctor Who, according to Andrew Hickey an entire series was rewritten at the last minute so that one of the Doctor’s assistants [...]

  9. Mindless Ones » Blog Archive » Doctor Who: Fifty Stories For Fifty Years: 1969 Says:

    [...] ‘Doctor’ and have the same theme music, there is literally nothing to connect, say, The Mind Robber from 1968 and Doctor Who And The Silurians from [...]

  10. Thrills Says:

    All the books of Orwell essays were out on loan at the library, but I shall persevere! Thanks for the ‘heads up’, regardless!

  11. Allan Says:

    WOW just what I was searching for. Came here by searching for design business with

    My site: casino online (Allan)

  12. låne penger på minuttet Says:

    For most recent news you have to pay a visit the
    web and on the web I found this site as a finest web page for most up-to-date updates.

    Here is my web-site … låne penger på minuttet

  13. candipharm Says:

    https://www.candipharm.com/#

  14. Morrislog Says:

    hydroxychloroquine pills https://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/#

  15. JamesGexia Says:

    https://over-the-counter-drug.com/# tamiflu over the counter

  16. Thomasautom Says:

    https://zithromax.science/# where to buy zithromax in canada

  17. Thomasautom Says:

    https://amoxil.science/# amoxicillin generic

  18. Thomasautom Says:

    https://stromectol.science/# ivermectin oral solution

  19. Kevininfob Says:

    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
    ivermectin price uk
    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.

  20. Zacharyadeve Says:

    Drugs information sheet. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
    https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol where to buy
    Get warning information here. Read now.

  21. Jamesindut Says:

    Long-Term Effects. Some trends of drugs.
    stromectol online pharmacy
    Some trends of drugs. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.

  22. Kevininfob Says:

    Some trends of drugs. Read now.
    ivermectin where to buy for humans
    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Read now.

  23. RonaldBer Says:

    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
    https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol nz
    All trends of medicament. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  24. Zacharyadeve Says:

    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
    https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 4000 mcg
    Read now. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  25. Kevininfob Says:

    Cautions. Everything information about medication.
    ivermectin price comparison
    Get here. Read here.

  26. Jessemople Says:

    Read now. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
    stromectol covid
    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Everything information about medication.

  27. RonaldBer Says:

    Read here. earch our drug database.
    ivermectin 80 mg
    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Get here.

  28. Kevininfob Says:

    Everything about medicine. Cautions.
    stromectol 15 mg
    Drug information. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.

  29. Zacharyadeve Says:

    Drugs information sheet. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
    https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 6mg dosage
    Drug information. Generic Name.

  30. RonaldBer Says:

    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Everything about medicine.
    https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 6
    Get here. Read here.

  31. Kevininfob Says:

    Drugs information sheet. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
    stromectol canada
    Generic Name. Read information now.

  32. Jessemople Says:

    Everything information about medication. All trends of medicament.
    ivermectin price canada
    Long-Term Effects. Long-Term Effects.

  33. Kevininfob Says:

    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
    https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol 12mg
    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.

  34. RonaldBer Says:

    Everything what you want to know about pills. Drugs information sheet.
    stromectol prices
    Read here. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  35. Zacharyadeve Says:

    Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Read information now.
    ivermectin 3 mg
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Long-Term Effects.

  36. Donaldtaf Says:

    Read here. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
    lisinopril for sale
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.

  37. DavidTrumn Says:

    Read information now. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
    where buy generic nexium without insurance
    Everything about medicine. All trends of medicament.

  38. JamesHog Says:

    Best and news about drug. п»їMedicament prescribing information. order cheap avodart no prescription
    earch our drug database. Get information now.

  39. WillieWem Says:

    Drug information. Get warning information here.
    can i buy nexium price
    Actual trends of drug. Long-Term Effects.

  40. Donaldtaf Says:

    safe and effective drugs are available. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
    can you get levaquin pill
    What side effects can this medication cause? Everything what you want to know about pills.

  41. Jameskex Says:

    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Actual trends of drug.
    generic lisinopril 3973
    Everything what you want to know about pills. All trends of medicament.

  42. DavidTrumn Says:

    Some trends of drugs. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
    https://nexium.top/# can i get cheap nexium price
    Some trends of drugs. Read here.

  43. WillieWem Says:

    earch our drug database. Cautions. https://avodart.science/# buy cheap avodart
    safe and effective drugs are available. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.

  44. Donaldtaf Says:

    Cautions. Drugs information sheet.
    where can i get mobic
    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.

  45. JamesHog Says:

    Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Drug information.
    buy 20mg lisinopril
    safe and effective drugs are available. Cautions.

  46. DavidTrumn Says:

    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. All trends of medicament.
    https://lisinopril.science/# lisinopril 20mg daily
    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. All trends of medicament.

  47. Jameskex Says:

    Best and news about drug. Drugs information sheet. https://avodart.science/# how can i get avodart without a prescription
    What side effects can this medication cause? Everything what you want to know about pills.

  48. WillieWem Says:

    Read information now. Medscape Drugs & Diseases. can i purchase cheap avodart without dr prescription
    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Top 100 Searched Drugs.

  49. Donaldtaf Says:

    Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. earch our drug database.
    cost generic levaquin pills
    Generic Name. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.

  50. DavidRew Says:

    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Read now.
    how to get zithromax online
    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.

  51. Aaronzek Says:

    Read here. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
    zithromax capsules 250mg
    Drugs information sheet. Long-Term Effects.

  52. DennisAbrat Says:

    safe and effective drugs are available. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
    https://finasteridest.com/ can i order propecia without a prescription
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Everything what you want to know about pills.

  53. DavidRew Says:

    Some trends of drugs. Best and news about drug. https://amoxicillins.com/ cost of amoxicillin 875 mg
    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Medicament prescribing information.

  54. DennisAbrat Says:

    Read now. Everything about medicine. https://amoxicillins.online/ amoxicillin buy canada
    earch our drug database. Everything what you want to know about pills.

  55. Donaldboove Says:

    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
    how can i get generic propecia pill
    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. п»їMedicament prescribing information.

  56. JamesGumma Says:

    Get here. Everything information about medication.
    cheap zithromax pills
    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Read here.

  57. Aaronzek Says:

    Read information now. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
    generic zithromax online paypal
    What side effects can this medication cause? п»їMedicament prescribing information.

  58. DavidRew Says:

    Best and news about drug. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
    where can i get generic clomid now
    All trends of medicament. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.

  59. JamesGumma Says:

    Best and news about drug. Get here.
    https://finasteridest.com/ where to buy cheap propecia pills
    Everything information about medication. earch our drug database.

  60. DavidRew Says:

    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Read information now.
    https://azithromycins.online/ zithromax antibiotic
    Medicament prescribing information. Read now.

  61. JamesGumma Says:

    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Get information now. amoxicillin without a prescription
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Read information now.

  62. Aaronzek Says:

    Generic Name. Read here.
    zithromax buy online no prescription
    Read here. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.

  63. Donaldboove Says:

    Everything information about medication. Everything information about medication.
    zithromax 1000 mg online
    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  64. DennisAbrat Says:

    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Read information now.
    https://azithromycins.com/ zithromax 500
    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Read now.

  65. DavidRew Says:

    Best and news about drug. Read here.
    https://azithromycins.com/ zithromax capsules australia
    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.

  66. Victorkah Says:

    Get here. Actual trends of drug.
    northwest canadian pharmacy
    п»їMedicament prescribing information. Read information now.

  67. Robertrar Says:

    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
    https://canadianfast.com/# pain meds online without doctor prescription
    Read here. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.

  68. EdgarFloal Says:

    Everything what you want to know about pills. Best and news about drug.
    https://canadianfast.com/# best canadian online pharmacy
    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Actual trends of drug.

  69. Jeffreyweerm Says:

    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
    my canadian pharmacy
    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Cautions.

  70. Jeffreyweerm Says:

    Drug information. earch our drug database.
    canadian drug
    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. п»їMedicament prescribing information.

  71. MichaelSox Says:

    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Drugs information sheet.
    cat antibiotics without pet prescription
    All trends of medicament. Generic Name.

  72. EdgarFloal Says:

    Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
    best online canadian pharmacy
    Best and news about drug. Drug information.

  73. Robertrar Says:

    Drugs information sheet. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
    https://canadianfast.com/# online canadian drugstore
    Drug information. п»їMedicament prescribing information.

  74. Victorkah Says:

    Get information now. Read here.
    prescription drugs canada buy online
    Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Read here.

  75. Jeffreyweerm Says:

    Everything information about medication. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
    reddit canadian pharmacy
    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Everything what you want to know about pills.

  76. Charlesmucky Says:

    Some trends of drugs. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
    chinese viagra manufacturers
    Some trends of drugs. Everything about medicine.

  77. BradleyExces Says:

    Get information now. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
    where can you buy sildenafil
    Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Read information now.

  78. Sammyletle Says:

    Read information now. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
    [url=https://viagrapillsild.online/#]buy viagra online australia fast delivery[/url]
    Everything about medicine. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  79. Charlesmucky Says:

    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Everything what you want to know about pills.
    average age for viagra
    Some trends of drugs. Get information now.

  80. BradleyExces Says:

    safe and effective drugs are available. Get warning information here.
    https://viagrapillsild.com/# sildenafil generic us
    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. What side effects can this medication cause?

  81. BillyShien Says:

    Read information now. Long-Term Effects.
    https://viagrapillsild.online/# sildenafil without a rx
    earch our drug database. What side effects can this medication cause?

  82. RobertLeply Says:

    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
    can i buy cialis local
    Some trends of drugs. Medicament prescribing information.

  83. Sammyletle Says:

    Read information now. Actual trends of drug.
    buy tadalafil 20
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Get warning information here.

  84. Willissip Says:

    Get warning information here. What side effects can this medication cause?
    cialis next day delivery
    Read information now. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.

  85. RobertLeply Says:

    Cautions. Read information now.
    https://tadalafil1st.com/# generic tadalafil 10mg
    Cautions. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.

  86. AlbertDor Says:

    Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Drug information.
    buy tadalafil from canada
    earch our drug database. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.

  87. MorrisEroge Says:

    Drugs information sheet. earch our drug database.
    cialis soft tabs canada
    Actual trends of drug. Some trends of drugs.

  88. Willissip Says:

    Long-Term Effects. Generic Name.
    https://tadalafil1st.online/# is 20mg cialis equal to 100mg viagra
    Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Cautions.

  89. Sammyletle Says:

    What side effects can this medication cause? Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
    cialis with no prescription
    Some trends of drugs. Read here.

  90. RobertLeply Says:

    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Long-Term Effects.
    tadalafil tablets canada
    Read information now. Generic Name.

  91. AlbertDor Says:

    Everything what you want to know about pills. Best and news about drug.
    tadalafil tablets canada
    Everything information about medication. Get warning information here.

  92. Willissip Says:

    Drugs information sheet. Get here.
    cialis online pharmacy australian
    Drugs information sheet. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.

  93. RobertLeply Says:

    Actual trends of drug. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
    https://tadalafil1st.online/# cialis pills for sale
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Cautions.

  94. MichaelFieva Says:

    safe and effective drugs are available. Everything what you want to know about pills.
    amoxicillin 500 mg cost
    Cautions. safe and effective drugs are available.

  95. MichaelFieva Says:

    drug information and news for professionals and consumers. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
    buy amoxil
    What side effects can this medication cause? Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.